Both get pitched as outsourced HR, and they solve different problems. One processes; one thinks. Here is how to tell which gap your organization actually has.
A PEO is a co-employment arrangement: it processes payroll, administers benefits, and handles transactional HR paperwork at scale, priced per employee. An HR consultant provides senior judgment: discipline and termination guidance, investigations, policies, supervisor development, and people systems tailored to your organization. PEOs excel at transactions. Consultants handle the decisions transactions cannot make. Many Texas employers use a payroll provider or PEO for administration and a consultant for judgment.
Payroll processing and tax filings. Access to larger-group benefits pricing. Workers' compensation coverage administration. HRIS technology and onboarding paperwork. Standardized handbooks and hotline support. Scale economics for administrative work, priced per employee.
Judgment on live situations: discipline, complaints, terminations, accommodations. On-site investigations. Policies built for your actual operation, including public sector and grant-funded environments PEOs handle poorly. Supervisor development. Systems that reduce how often problems occur, priced as a flat monthly retainer.
Payroll errors, benefits enrollment chaos, filings missed. A PEO or a strong payroll provider fixes this. A consultant is the wrong tool.
The owner is personally handling employee issues. Supervisors document nothing. A termination is looming and nobody is sure it is safe. No per-employee fee fixes this; senior judgment does.
Common at 20 to 100 employees. Pair a transactional provider with a fractional HR consultant, and each dollar buys what it is actually good at. Municipalities and nonprofits should note that co-employment often fits public and grant-funded environments awkwardly, which is why our public sector clients typically run payroll internally with consulting layered on top.
In a PEO arrangement, your employees are also employed by the PEO for tax and benefits purposes. You keep day-to-day direction of the work; the PEO becomes the employer of record for payroll and benefits administration.
PEOs typically provide hotline-level guidance and template documents. They are not in your building, do not know your supervisors, and will not sit with you through a termination decision or run an on-site investigation. That gap is exactly where consultants live.
They price differently: PEOs charge per employee per month or a percentage of payroll, and the total often exceeds a consulting retainer well before 50 employees. Many employers pay for both without realizing the PEO's HR layer goes unused.
Yes, and it is a common structure: the PEO handles payroll, benefits, and filings, while the consultant owns judgment, systems, supervisor capability, and the decisions that carry legal risk.
When you want your benefits identity back, the per-employee fees have outgrown their value, or you have internal admin capacity and mainly lack senior HR judgment. We help employers evaluate that transition honestly.
Book a no-cost 30-minute consult. Describe your situation, get a straight recommendation and a clear quote, and decide with real numbers in front of you.
Not ready for a call? Take the free HR System Risk Diagnostic.